Topic: What is the basis of a fair challenge?

[FPF-DieHard]

- Solo Escorts are BS and should be banned from now until the end of time.

- Klink Carriers suck.   The only one the Klinks even fly is the D6U and that is hardly a warrior's ship.

- Bombardment ships have been done to death.

Restrict all the crappy cheesy junk that infest other servers.  Let the warriors battle in real ships.

[KAT Chuut-Ritt]

Restrict all the crappy cheesy junk that infest other servers.  Let the warriors battle in real ships.

That would be The Kzin Civil War.......

[madelf]

- Solo Escorts are BS and should be banned from now until the end of time.

- Klink Carriers suck.   The only one the Klinks even fly is the D6U and that is hardly a warrior's ship.

- Bombardment ships have been done to death.

Restrict all the crappy cheesy junk that infest other servers.  Let the warriors battle in real ships.

Cheers for DH!

[madelf]

Restrict all the crappy cheesy junk that infest other servers.  Let the warriors battle in real ships.

That would be The Kzin Civil War.......

Kzin Civil War Rules:
"PvP will be strictly banned.  A Kzin warrior is a master comp stomper, we do not waste time trying to defeat players, since we know it isn't possible"
"All houses will play on servers by themselves with no opposition, besides the AI.  AT the end of the server run, the total economy will be tallied up, and whomever with the highest wins."
"To make things easier, all ouse leaders will whine their combat ships arn't effective enough, and need more drones/AMD."
 

[Laflin]

WAAAAAH!

[KAT Chuut-Ritt]

Restrict all the crappy cheesy junk that infest other servers.  Let the warriors battle in real ships.

That would be The Kzin Civil War.......

Kzin Civil War Rules:
"PvP will be strictly banned.  A Kzin warrior is a master comp stomper, we do not waste time trying to defeat players, since we know it isn't possible"
"All houses will play on servers by themselves with no opposition, besides the AI.  AT the end of the server run, the total economy will be tallied up, and whomever with the highest wins."
"To make things easier, all ouse leaders will whine their combat ships arn't effective enough, and need more drones/AMD."
 

LOL nice post

But seriously,

Real Warriors use the Phaser 3

[_SSCF_Hooch]

bump 2

[ShadowLord]

This is a very good question with no clear cut answer..
I wonder if it might not be easier to arrange something like this ..


Informal/Impromptu challenges are handled as per the rules, after all your not required to accept them so -- if two/four/six pilots show up in a battle and agree they have fair ships to fight with for a challenge issue so be it..

alternative rules?

How about all formal challenges get resolved on GSA using one of several pre set ships -- say one possible choice from each hull class ..
Ie
FWL
D5L
C7
or
D5k
FDW
FWK --
whatever the ships are doesn't really matter as the other person will get the exact same ship..now here is the one variable -- the person who got challenged gets to pick which ships will be used to resolve combat.. perhaps the C7 and DN class should only be reserved for those pilots flying them in the campaign..

Anyways just an idea..

ShadowLord

[KHH Jakle]

All challenges should be resolved on GSA with each player using a stock, unrefitted D6.......

 

[FPF-DieHard]

All challenges should be resolved on GSA with each player using a stock, unrefitted D6.......

 

How about we meet personally, kick each other in the 'nads until one of us drops?

[KBF-Frankk]

Restrict all the crappy cheesy junk that infest other servers.  Let the warriors battle in real ships.

That would be The Kzin Civil War.......

Kzin Civil War Rules:
"PvP will be strictly banned.  A Kzin warrior is a master comp stomper, we do not waste time trying to defeat players, since we know it isn't possible"
"All houses will play on servers by themselves with no opposition, besides the AI.  AT the end of the server run, the total economy will be tallied up, and whomever with the highest wins."
"To make things easier, all ouse leaders will whine their combat ships arn't effective enough, and need more drones/AMD."
 

LOL nice post

But seriously,

Real Warriors use the Phaser 3

Nope, REAL WARRIORS fly in F5 

[Hexx]

All challenges should be resolved on GSA with each player using a stock, unrefitted D6.......

 

How about we meet personally, kick each other in the 'nads until one of us drops?

I'll go first then forfeit the VP and withdraw...

[Strafer]

My take for a fair challenge is Tournament. Start a GSA Tournament scenario and pick your race. If you're Rom you get a little randomness...

[KAT Chuut-Ritt]

Restrict all the crappy cheesy junk that infest other servers.  Let the warriors battle in real ships.

That would be The Kzin Civil War.......

Kzin Civil War Rules:
"PvP will be strictly banned.  A Kzin warrior is a master comp stomper, we do not waste time trying to defeat players, since we know it isn't possible"
"All houses will play on servers by themselves with no opposition, besides the AI.  AT the end of the server run, the total economy will be tallied up, and whomever with the highest wins."
"To make things easier, all ouse leaders will whine their combat ships arn't effective enough, and need more drones/AMD."
 

LOL nice post

But seriously,

Real Warriors use the Phaser 3

Nope, REAL WARRIORS fly in F5 

And don't bitch about it.....

[KBF-Frankk]

Restrict all the crappy cheesy junk that infest other servers.  Let the warriors battle in real ships.

That would be The Kzin Civil War.......

Kzin Civil War Rules:
"PvP will be strictly banned.  A Kzin warrior is a master comp stomper, we do not waste time trying to defeat players, since we know it isn't possible"
"All houses will play on servers by themselves with no opposition, besides the AI.  AT the end of the server run, the total economy will be tallied up, and whomever with the highest wins."
"To make things easier, all ouse leaders will whine their combat ships arn't effective enough, and need more drones/AMD."
 

LOL nice post

But seriously,

Real Warriors use the Phaser 3
[/quote

Nope, REAL WARRIORS fly in F5 

And don't bitch about it.....

 

Hablando en serio, si es una guerra civil, las naves disponibles deberían de ser únicamente fragatas tales como G2 y F5, asi se sabría quien es quien.

 

[_SSCF_Hooch]

Come guys get to voting, I don't want any hanging chads.   

[Hexx]

I'm trying but it won't let me do it again..

[KAT Chuut-Ritt]

Come guys get to voting, I don't want any hanging chads.   

Those things dangling from Kroma's Ballet are not chads......

[madelf]

All challenges should be resolved on GSA with each player using a stock, unrefitted D6.......

 

How about we meet personally, kick each other in the 'nads until one of us drops?

I'll go first then forfeit the VP and withdraw...

And I'd let you go first every time.  Everyone knows I'd put my balls on the line for the empire.

[KAT Chuut-Ritt]

All challenges should be resolved on GSA with each player using a stock, unrefitted D6.......

 

How about we meet personally, kick each other in the 'nads until one of us drops?

I'll go first then forfeit the VP and withdraw...

And I'd let you go first every time.  Everyone knows I'd put my balls on the line for the empire.

Lets tell the truth here Madelf, you just don't think Hexx can kick that high......